Every therapist knows the feeling of a well-placed, reflective question falling flat. I might ask “What do you think that feeling is about?” as a way of trying to guide a patient toward the deep and unknown connections driving their emotional life — and instead receive a lengthy story about the events leading up to the feeling. Or an intellectual explanation of how the feeling connects with their interpretation of events. If the patient is fairly concrete or disconnected from emotion, they may shut down the inquiry with a simple “I don’t know.” Or, worst of all, the question may come off as a criticism, as though I were asking “Why do you feel that way?”
As I argued in How to Succeed or Fail as a Psychotherapist, the foundation of all effective therapy work is the mentalizing stance. But how do we invite our patients to join us in a reflective mode, when our questions about meaning fall flat?

Mentalizing Questions and Failures
- “What’s that about?”
- “What could that mean?”
- “Where do you think that comes from?”
- “How do you make sense of that?”
When these questions don’t have the desired effect, it’s easy for our own mentalizing mode to fail:
We might fall into a teleological mode, trying to force a change by “challenging” their thoughts.
Or slip into a pretend mode, offering detached “interpretations” of their responses.
Or, becoming lost (“embedded”) in the story they tell, we might fall into psychic equivalence, treating their memory of an event as if it were the main event, instead of the living relationship happening in the room.
Here’s an alternative: what if instead of asking for reflection on meaning, we instead ask for reflection on function? Questions like…
- “How does that work?”
- “How is it that you come to feel that way?”
- “What do you think might be driving that?”
- “Do you have a sense for why that’s needed?”
- “What purpose could that be serving?”
- “What do you think that might be doing for you?”
And, of course, ‘wondering aloud’ reflections tend to be better than questions. They soften the inquiry, reduce the demand for a specific answer, and model a curious, non-judgmental stance. This approach invites collaboration rather than positioning you as the expert who requires an answer. So let’s brainstorm some, with an eye on staying grounded in the moment…
- “I wonder what keeps you from wanting to stay with that.”
- “I’m curious about what might be driving that impulse for you now.”
- “I wonder if there’s something we’re not paying attention to right now.”
These get us closer, moving away from the demand of a direct question. But they remain a bit ambiguous, still kind of vaguely pointing toward meaning. They don’t anchor the inquiry in function, so it would be easy for the focus to remain on the content of what’s being discussed rather than the process of discussing it.
The key, I’m beginning to think, isn’t just to wonder aloud, but to build the query about function directly into the reflection itself. To wonder not just what, but what for. Like this:
- “I notice a shift in your thought process here, I wonder what that’s for.”
- “It’s almost like your mind tries to prevent us from getting close to something here.”
- “Maybe there’s something that feeling wants to protect you from.”
- “I’m curious how that might be useful.”
These are much closer to functional reflections, I think. So the principle is that in order to reflect on function, we have to keep in mind what sorts of functions an unconscious process could actually accomplish. Things like self-protection, prevention of harm, or fulfilling a need.
The first job of building reflective function isn’t just to reflect, but to discover that reflection is even necessary or possible. So, by helping a patient start to wonder about the job of their anxiety, or the protective function of their anger, we help them see that their anger and anxiety are unconscious phenomena: they are motivated by something, but we don’t know what. Recognizing the unconscious nature of mental phenomena also serves to de-identify, or dis-embed us from the phenomenon. Not “I’m angry,” but “I’ve got some angry feelings I’d like to understand.” This is the reflective stance toward experience.